James Wierzbicki / writings

William Bolcom

interview with the composer re: "Symphony No. 4 (The Rose)"
interview with the composer re: "Songs of Innocence and Experience"
review of "Songs of Innocence and Experience"
review of "McTeague"
interview with the composer re: "Symphony No. 4 (The Rose)"
MOST COMPOSERS who write pieces involving poetry hope that audiences will familiarize themselves with the text before hearing the music.

In the case of William Bolcom, whose Symphony No. 4 will be premiered in Powell Hall next weekend by conductor Leonard Slatkin and the St. Louis Symphony, the hope is especially intense.

Not that it's necessary to know the poem ahead of time in order to understand it. On the contrary, it's a long but verbally simple poem, and Bolcom has deliberately set it in a way that promises to make its content intelligible to any listener on first hearing. And just in case his mostly syllabic treatments of the words and their generally transparent accompaniments aren't enough to make things perfectly clear, he suggests that the mezzo-soprano soloist be amplified so that she can pay particular attention to matters of diction and nuance.

Homework is not required. Nevertheless, Bolcom says, an advance reading of the text - even if it takes place moments before the performance - would give audience members an enormous advantage in appreciating what the entire symphony is about.

The two-movement composition, which features the words of Theodore Roethke's ''The Rose'' only in its second half, is - like the poem itself - a meditation on nature, Bolcom sa ys. At least from the philosophical standpoint, the meditation has been in the making for more than 30 years; although deeply personal and to a large extent autobiographical, it's a meditation, Bolcom feels, that might well strike familiar chords with persons who take the time to do their own reflecting on Roethke's imagery.

Bolcom, 48, grew up in Seattle, and some of his earliest memories have to do with seascapes of the sort described in ''The Rose.''

''It's not about a specific place,'' Bolcom says of the poem. ''But it's about a special place, a magical place. When you know a place really well, your mind keeps journeying back to it. You remember the way it looked, but mostly you remember the way it felt. The main thing I remember from my childhood is going to the beach and looking for oysters. What I recall most vividly is the feeling of those early mornings at the ocean, absolutely quiet and softened by rolling gray clouds. I'm not sure what place Roethke had in mind when he wrote 'The Rose.' It doesn't matter, because the poem, for me, projects the same sort of heavy, dark-blue feeling I get when I think about the Pacific Northwest.''

Actually, ''The Rose'' might have been inspired by the same place Bolcom remembers. Roethke was born in 1908 in Saginaw, Mich. He grew up in the Midwest and studied at the University of Michigan and at Harvard. He held teaching various positions east of the Mississippi while his reputation as a poet grew. But he spent most of the last 16 years of his life not far from Bolcom's beach. In 1947 Roethke joined the faculty of the University of Washington in Seattle, and it was there - during the 1956-57 academic year - that he met Bolcom.

Roethke was by that time a Pulitzer Prize winner (for his 1953 collection ''The Waking''), and Bolcom was just an 18-year-old composition student taking an elective class in poetry so that he might learn something about how to set words to music. Roethke's impressions of Bolcom remain undocumented. But Bolcom has written - in the liner notes for the Nonesuch recording of his 1975 Roethke-based song-cycle ''Open House'' - of what his encounters with the poet meant to him:

''Roethke was not an easy man to know, but his artistic struggle and evolution seem familiar to me - perhaps even similar to my own. In his early years Roethke adopted an avant-garde, almost stream-of-consciousness 'Freudian' style; later he was to become more and more classically oriented . . . although a respect for the works of the past is already obvious in his first publications.''

Bolcom's development indeed parallels Roethke's.

These days, Bolcom is best known as a pianist who records albums of ragtime music and - with his wife, mezzo-soprano Joan Morris - vintage popular songs. As a composer, he's generally regarded as an eclectic who freely appropriates whatever musical styles suit his expressive needs but whose methods of organizing materials basically hold to traditional lines. He's a fairly conservative modern composer, but there was a time when he willingly embraced the most radical of avant-garde ideas.

''In 1960 I attended classes at the summer school of music in Darmstadt, West Germany,'' Bolcom said in a telephone interview last week. ''Boulez, Stockhausen and Berio were there, and, like any young student, I was very much impressed by their theories of serialism.

''But I couldn't accept what they said about the need for composers to cut themselves off from their past. I guess they needed to do it, because it was their collective past that led up to World War II. For them, the past was an awful thing, so they had to do whatever they could - musically - to destroy it.

''I didn't need to destroy my past, though. I realized that serial music, or any kind of avant-garde music, contained resources that could be of use to me. But I wanted to integrate those resources with the resources of older musical languages. I've been trying to do that for the last 25 years.''

Bolcom's attempts at integration typically have been overt.

In 1963, after producing several instrumental works in the serial vein, Bolcom composed a one-act opera - ''Dynamite Tonite!'' - that includes numbers in the style of pop songs from the World War I period. He modeled a theme in his 1965 String Quartet No. 8 on a rock-and-roll tune, and in the same year he sprinkled a piece called ''Session I'' with jazz flavorings. Bolcom's 1967 ''Session IV'' features direct quotes from Beethoven and Schubert along with passages written in imitation of Scott Joplin rags; references to ragtime appear as well in his 1967 ''Black Host'' for organ, percussion and electronic tape and in his 1976 Piano Concerto, and his 1976 Piano Quartet incorporates into its mix a Chopin barcarolle and an ancient Indonesian ''monkey chant.''

In most of his recent pieces, however, Bolcom pays homage to the past in more subtle ways.

The new Symphony No. 4, for example, contains no paraphrases of earlier music, and its only allusions to pre-existing sounds of any sort are the bird-call-l ike figurations that decorate the text's lines about gulls, kingfishers and the like. In fact, the Symphony's content, especially in the opening instrumental movement, is quite thoroughly modernistic. Like the later poems of Roethke, however, this very modern-sounding opening movement is eminently classical in its design.

''It evokes the traditional sonata form in its outline,'' Bolcom said. ''The shape is a sort of inverse wedge; it starts out with high intensity and then becomes meditative, rather the opposite of what usually happens in symphonies. But underneath all the dissonance is a tonal structure that has a lot in common with everything the symphony - as a form - used to be. It's a particular hierarchical structure that makes sense; it's the underpinning of all of 18th- and 19th-century music.

''Roethke, toward the end of his life, was rediscovering the simple roots of language. He explored traditional forms. He didn't imitate them, but in poems like 'The Rose' he did, in a way, refer to them.

''I'm trying to do the same thing in music, to get back to the simple roots, to refer to the past without actually imitating it. The second movement of the Symphony, in which I use the Roethke poem, is about my personal past; the first movement is about the musical past in general, a past with which I've always been intimately involved.''

St. Louis Post-Dispatch    March. 8, 1987
interview with the composer re: "Songs of Innocence and Experience"
CHICAGO -- CHICAGO LYRIC OPERA general director Ardis Krainik had reason for caution when, in the spring of 1986, she was advised to offer a commission to William Bolcom. At the time, Bolcom's only works for the stage amounted to a handful of lightweight ''cabaret operas'' - written for actors, not singers - he'd produced in the mid-1960s.

In 1982, however, Bolcom had brought to completion a three-hour setting of William Blake poems that had occupied his attention off and on for almost a quarter-century. Bolcom's gigantic ''Songs of Innocence and Experience'' is neither an opera nor an oratorio, but it is nonetheless dramatic in concept, and in its free-flowing mix of styles it is tellingly representative of what Bolcom the composer is all about. Under the baton of Dennis Russell Davies, the Blake treatment was premiered in January of 1984 at the Stuttgart Opera. A few months later it was performed at the University of Michigan, where Bolcom teaches, and in the summer of 1986 - to Krainik's delight - it was encored at Grant Park in Chicago. Bolcom's contract with the Lyric Opera would not be officially announced until 1989, a year after Bolcom won the Pulitzer Prize for his ''Twelve New Etudes'' for piano. But the Lyric's director says that as soon as she heard ''Songs of Innocence and Experience'' she knew that Bolcom was indeed her man.

''Songs of Innocence and Experience'' - which will be presented by Leonard Slatkin and the St. Louis Symphony in Powell Hall on Thursday and Friday - calls for not only chorus and orchestra but also a narrator, nine conventional vocal soloists and a rock singer. Its forces are grand and its duration long, yet it is primarily for its content that it looms so large. A significant part of that content, certainly, is found in the music. As does his new opera ''McTeague,'' Bolcom's ''Songs of Innocence and Experience'' covers a lot of stylistic territory. Some passages are blatantly tonal and tuneful, others abrasively dissonant. There are references to jazz, gospel, rock, ragtime and other popular idioms; there are also whole sections in which the musical foundation, no matter what the surface material, is based on the methods of 12-tone serialism. Together, these styles add up to what for Bolcom is a single style he calls ''the American musical vernacular.'' Listeners might be tempted to call this approach ''eclectic,'' but Bolcom finds the word not at all to his liking.

''Eclecticism,'' he said in an interview last week, ''assumes that all the categories are water-tight. In fact, all of these different kinds of music spill over into the others. They already have elements in common; they already are interpenetrating. Especially in the last few decades, composers and critics have wasted time arguing about which style - jazz or rock or classical - is the most valid. The way I see it, they're all valid, and my concern is figuring out how they all relate to one another. But it's indisputable that they do relate, and so out of them can be forged a single musical language that is as vital - and as inclusive - as the English language.

''This is what Charles Ives was trying to do, and Gershwin, and Duke Ellington. And it's what I've been trying to do for most of my career. I think I'm there. I mean, I'm using this language, and audiences seem to be understanding it. Sure, I meet with resistance, but it only comes from people with case-hardened notions of musical categories.''

Bolcom's music, then, might be self-explanatory. But the content of ''Songs of Innocence and Experience'' is as much poetic as musical. And for most Americans, the author of that poetry is a mystery.

William Blake was born in London in 1757 and died there in 1827. He was a mystic; when his brother died, he claimed to see the spirit rise from the body and pass slowly through the ceiling of the room. He was also a visual artist: Taught, he said, by the ghost of his dead brother, Blake pioneered a variety of etching techniques and used them to illustrate his poems. During his lifetime Blake was dismissed as a madman, and his poems did not gain wide circulation until late in the 19th century. Most of them are short and in the lyrical, odic vein. Probably the best known is the one that begins ''Tiger, tiger, burning bright . . . .''

In the essay that accompanies the St. Louis performances, Bolcom writes: ''William Blake is to me the most urgent of poets. What he says is as immediate as ever, but particularly to us. He came from an epoch of social change as total as ours, and we can learn from him in the time of our deepest human crisis, that of whether or not we will survive as a planet. With clear and unjudging vision, Blake saw where the human race was heading; it could be argued that (Blake's) 'Songs of Innocence and Experience' may be the clearest explanation we have of what forces have brought us to this frightening impasse.''

The statement is provocative, to say the least, and I asked Bolcom to expand on it.

''I have found solace in Blake ever since I was about 15 years old,'' Bolcom said. ''In terms of my music, he showed me the way to go. He was a very educated man, steeped in the classics, but he also knew the value of the song off the street, and he had no problem in blending the elements of all the literary styles he knew. There's more to it than that, of course. The prophetic books talk about missed opportunities in the history of the human race, about the rise of governments that could not be constructive because of some basic flaw, about the prevalence of certain attitudes that can only cause holocaust and misery. Much of this stems from our unwillingness to confront what we, as humans, really are; it's just too frightening to face. But Blake tells us what we are, and he contrasts this with what we think we are. We have innocent notions about ourselves, and sometimes we go around in a stupor because we actually believe them. Experience, on the other hand, teaches us something else.

''All around us are examples of innocence pitted against experience. Our politicians suggest that we be puritanical, yet our entire advertising industry is based on the idea of sexual titillation. On one page of a woman's magazine there is an article about dieting and on the next page is a recipe for the richest dessert you can imagine. We see pleasant little sitcoms on TV, and in the commercial breaks we see ads for anti-drug campaigns. How can you expect people to deal with these contradictions? But it is precisely contradictions of this sort that form the central theme of Blake's work. Blake, more than any other poet, dealt with the truth of human nature. And he did it in a hopeful, not a pessimistic way, because he realized that only when people face up to what they really are can they know joy.

''I think that joy, ultimately, is what my setting of Blake's poems is all about. I don't mean just happiness. I mean joy, the kind you find at the end of 'The Book of Job'; after the worst things that could possibly happen to him, Job is left with joy, because finally God tells him the truth about himself. That's it, in a nutshell. In truth there is joy.''

St. Louis Post-Dispatch    Nov. 8, 1992
review of "Songs of Innocence and Experience"
''CRUELTY has a human heart/And jealousy a human face/Terror, the human form divine . . . .''

As appraisals of our species go, this one - by the late 18th- and early 19th-century English poet William Blake - ranks among the most bluntly honest. It comes at the very end of composer William Bolcom's 1982 setting of Blake's ''Songs of Innocence and Experience,'' after an hour of blithe optimism and then a 90-minute descent into the darkest regions of the human spirit.

Indeed, so grim are the pictures Bolcom paints after intermission that as the final song begins it is hard to remember the evening contained any bright spots at all. Instead of driving home his point with a complete and utter emotional black-out, though, Bolcom goes for the ironic twist. The last number is a reggae song; the words ought to make us feel ashamed of ourselves, yet the music - as joyous as any on the planet - makes us want to get up and dance.

Powell Hall was not at all packed for the St. Louis Symphony's performance of Bolcom's ''Songs of Innocence and Experience'' under the direction of Leonard Slatkin on Thursday night. But those in attendance must surely know that they witnessed a major musical event.

The score is remarkable for reasons aside from its uncommon length and its awesome expressive power. It represents what Bolcom calls the ''American vernacular musical language.'' It is not an ''eclectic'' piece that borrows bits of this and that to flavor an otherwise mainstream modernist style. Rather, the score blends virtually all the music with which Bolcom is familiar - with which most Americans are familiar - into a cogent whole. The idioms of the concert hall are here, but so are the idioms of the saloon, the church, the fraternity house, the grand ol' opry. Bolcom's musical contrasts are often bold, and the bleak-texted reggae segment is not his only use of irony. No matter how bold or ironic, though, the various elements never seem forced or gimmicky. On the contrary, they feel exactly right for whatever level of his multitiered message Bolcom is trying to get across at any given moment. And they all sound convincing. The gloomy song titled ''London'' was not an example of the St. Louis Symphony simply making reference to heavy metal rock music; for as long as it lasted, this was the real thing, complete with throbbing tom-toms and fiercely over-driven electric guitar.

Andre De Shields was the always-compelling rock and reggae singer. His colleagues are so numerous they can only be named here. The country singer was Lee Anna Knox, the torch singer and folk balladeer Debby Lennon, the lyric soprano Linda Hohenfeld, the dramatic soprano Mary Shearer, the coloratura Ilana Davidson, the tenors Walter Plante and John Absolom, the baritone Vernon Hartman, the boy narrator Jordan Cooper. The New York-based sextet called the Western Wind sang the madrigals; the massed voices were those of the St. Louis Symphony Chorus and the Concert Choir of the St. Louis Children's Choir.

Bolcom's ''Songs of Innocence and Experience'' is significant for its size and range and for its almost-unique synthesis of musical idioms. But it is more significant for its painfully accurate treatment of the poetry. To absorb the music is much, much easier than to contemplate Blake's assessment of what it means to be human. In this, too, there is irony.

St. Louis Post-Dispatch    Nov. 14, 1992
review of "McTeague"
CHICAGO -- WILLIAM BOLCOM'S ''McTeague,'' which premiered last weekend at the Chicago Lyric Opera, seems as much destined for success as its characters are doomed to failure. In an age when new works are typically layered with metaphor or caught up in reflections on opera's past, this one is content to tell a simple story.

Like the 1899 novel by Frank Norris on which it is based, Bolcom's ''McTeague'' is about greed. Gold is the dominant visual image in Yuri Kuper's set design and in Robert Altman's staging; the dynamics of corruption - of good turning to bad and then to worse - provide the basic shape of Bolcom's music. Even in the first scene, one knows how the opera will end; when the final curtain falls, the inevitable tragedy strikes unsettlingly close to home.

Although the Lyric Opera has lately been paying considerable attention to the music of living American composers, ''McTeague'' is the company's first world premiere since Krzysztof Penderecki's ''Paradise Lost'' in 1978. That it comes from Bolcom is significant, for Bolcom - more than any of his contemporaries - is on a path that may well lead to the future of opera in this country. His thoughts on what he terms the ''American musical vernacular'' are detailed in the accompanying story; they are realized, with full dramatic effect, in every moment of ''McTeague.''

Bolcom's opera, to be sure, taps the resources of pre-existing musical genres. It is set in San Francisco at the turn of the century, and to conjure up a period atmosphere Bolcom alludes to concertina ditties, cowboy songs, cakewalks and the like. But these are never isolated from the rest of the score or showcased, like museum pieces, as objects perhaps worthy of contemplation. As befits a dramatic work about lust and violence, the music often erupts with shocking force. In terms of musical style, though, none of the gestures seems totally surprising. There is a balance here between tonality and its opposite, between lyric melody and crunching discord, between propulsive dance rhythms and weightless harmonic vapors. The old-fashioned bits are just a few threads among many that Bolcom has woven into a consistent fabric that feels right for the times. ''McTeague'' is modern opera, not postmodern.

The Chicago production features tenor Ben Heppner in the title role and soprano Catherine Malfitano as his miserly wife, Trina. Both of them, presumably, were cast with their physiques in mind. As novelist Norris told the story, McTeague is as big as an ox if not quite so dumb, and at first he is attracted to Trina in large part because of her fragile feminine beauty. Later he beats Trina to death, and the scene in the opera seems all the more gruesome because of the contrast in the singers' bodies.

Heppner and Malfitano, well-known on the international opera circuit, were in fine vocal form at the Oct. 31 premiere. So were mezzo-soprano Emily Golden as Maria, a cryptic charwoman infatuated with the idea of wealth, and baritone Timothy Nolen as Schouler, the jealous sidekick who turns out to be McTeague's worst enemy. The acting all around was credible; it was especially impressive in the chilly love scene during which Maria and Schouler reach orgasm by independently fantasizing about gold.

Altman, as noted above, was the stage director, but he also served as the opera's co-librettist; indeed, it was Altman who re-shaped Norris' novel into a two-act opera linked by quasi-cinematic flashback scenes, and his partner, Arnold Weinstein, simply came up with the characters' blunt, brutal words. Most of those words, but not Malfitano's, were clear as a bell at the premiere; it's probably a good thing that the entire text, as it unfolded, was projected on a screen above the proscenium.

''McTeague,'' expertly conducted by longtime Bolcom champion Dennis Russell Davies, will be repeated at the Civic Opera House on Monday and Thursday and Nov. 1 5, 18, 21 and 24.

St. Louis Post-Dispatch    Nov. 8, 1992
Return to Writings index
Return to James Wierzbicki's home page